L’'esegesi topica' di Pietro Abelardo nel Commento all’Epistola ai Romani (11,16-24) Peter Abelard’s ‘Topical Exegesis’ in the Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans (11, 16–24)

Main Article Content

Fiorella Magnano


Although many scholars have stressed the dialectical structure of Peter Abelard’s theological works, the total absence of studies concerning the use of dialectical topics into his theological discourse is surprising. Therefore, this study aims to draw attention on this specific aspect of Abelard’s theological works, in order to illustrate the way in which the dialectical topics, exposed in a logical context, were subsequently put into service of the Sacred Scripture to explore its sense. My conclusions are that the ‘topical exegesis’ represents the space of autonomy assigned to human reason in search of a foundation, if not rational at least reasonable, of the high degree of verisimilitude of Revelation’s content.

Article Details





Agostino d’Ippona, De doctrina christiana, PL 34, 15–121, ed. Josef Martin, Brepols, Turnhout 1962 (CCSL, 32).

Anicio Manlio Severino Boezio, De hypotheticis syllogismis, testo, traduzione, introduzione e commento di Luca Obertello, Paideia, Brescia 1969.

Abelardo, Dialectica, ed. Lambertus Marie de Rjik, Van Gorcum, Assen 1970.

— Super Topica Glossae, in Id., Scritti di logica, ed. Mario Dal Pra, La Nuova Italia, Firenze 1969, p. 205–330.

— Commentaria in epistolam ad Romanos, PL 178, 783A, in Éloi Marie Buytaert (ed.), Turnhout, Brepols, 1969 (CCCM, 11).

— Expositio in Epistolam ad Romanos – Römerbriefkommentar, ed. Rolf Peppermüller, 3 vol., Herder, Freiburg 2000.

— Peter Abelard, Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, ed. Steven R. Cartwright, Catholic University of America Press, Washington 2011.

— Abelardo, Teologia del sommo bene, trad. it. a cura di Marco Rossini, Bompiani, Milano 2003.

Tommaso d’Aquino, Expositio et lectura super Epistolas Pauli Apostoli, I: Lettera ai Romani, a cura di Battista Mondin, Edizioni Studio Domenicano, Bologna 1910.


Affeldt, Werner, Die weltliche Gewalt in der Paulus-Exegese. Rom. 13,1–7 in den Romerbriesskommentaren der lateinischen Kirche bis zum Ende des XIII. Jahrhunderts, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Gottingen 1969.

Aletti, Jean-Noël, « La présence d’un modèle rhétorique en Romains. Son rôle et son importance », Biblica, 71 (1990), p. 1–24.

— « La dispositio rhétorique dans les épîtres pauliniennes: propositions de méthode », Journal of the Study of the New Testament Studies, 38 (1992), p. 385–401.

— La lettera ai Romani e la giustizia di Dio, Borla, Roma 1997.

Baxter, Alan G., John A. Ziesler, « Paul and Arburiculture: Romans 11,17-24 », Journal for the Study of the New Testament, 24 (1985), p. 25–32.

Beonio-Brocchieri Fumagalli, Maria Teresa, La logica di Abelardo, La Nuova Italia, Firenze 1969.

— Introduzione ad Abelardo, Laterza, Roma–Bari 1974.

Biard, ‪Joël (ed.), Langage, sciences, philosophie au XIIe siècle. Actes de la Table ronde internationale (25–26 mars 1998), Vrin, Paris 1999.‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬

Bourke, Myles M., A Study of Metaphor of the Olive Tree in Romans 11, Catholic University of America Press, Washington 1947.

Campbell, William S., Peter S. Hawkins, Brenda Deen Schildgen (eds.), Medieval Readings of Romans, T&T Clark International, New York 2007 (Romans through History and Cultures Series).

Cartwright, Steven R., « The Romans Commentaries of William of St. Thierry and Peter Abelard: A Theological and Methodological Comparison », Ph.D. Diss., Western Michigan University, 2001.

— « Twelfth-Century Pauline Exegesis: William of St. Thierry’s Monastic Rhetoric and Peter Abelard’s Scholastic Logic », in Steven Cartwright (ed.), A Companion to St. Paul in the Middle Ages, Brill, Leiden–Boston 2013 (Brill’s Companions to the Christian Tradition), p. 205–234.

Cottiaux, Jean, « La conception de la théologie chez Abélard », Revue d’histoire ecclésiastique, 28 (1932), p. 247–295.

Daube, David, « Rabbinic Methods of Interpretation and Hellenistic Rhetoric », Hebrew Union College Annual, 22 (1949), p. 239–264.

— « Alexandrian Methods of Interpretation and the Rabbis », in Festschrift Hans Lewaid bei Vollendung des vierzigsten Amtsjahres als ordentlicher Professor im Oktober 1953, Helbig & Lichtenhahn, Basel 1953, p. 27-44.

Davies, William David, Paul and the Gentiles: A Suggestion Concerning Romans 11:13–24, in Id. (ed.), Pauline and Jewish Studies, Fortress, Philadelphia 1984, p. 153–163 e 356–360.

Denifle, Heinrich, Die abendlandischen Schriftausleger bis Euther über Justitia Dei (Rom. 1,17) und Justificatio, Kirchheim, Mainz 1905.

d’Onofrio, Giulio, Topica e sapere teologico nell’alto Medioevo, in Joël Biard, Fosca Mariani Zini (eds.), Les lieux de l’argumentation. Histoire du syllogisme topique d’Aristote à Leibniz, Brepols, Turnhout 2009 (Studia Artistarum, 22), p. 141–170.

Esler, Philip F., « Ancient Oleiculture and Ethnic Differentiation: The Meaning of the Olive-Tree Image in Romans 11 », Journal for the Study of the New Testament, 26 (2003), p. 103–124.

Evans, Gillian Rosemary, The Language and Logic of the Bible the Earlier Middle Ages, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1984.

Havemann, John C. T., « Cultivated Olive Tree – Wild Olive: The Olive Tree Metaphor in Romans 11:16,24 », Neot, 31 (1997), p. 87–106.

Jolivet, Jean, Arts du langage et théologie chez Abélard, Vrin, Paris 1982.

La Bibbia nell’Alto Medioevo, Centro Italiano di Studi sull’alto Medioevo, Spoleto 1963 (Settimane di Studio del Centro Italiano di studi dell’Alto Medioevo, 10).

Maartens, Paul J., « Inference and Relevance in Paul’s Allegory of the Wild Olive Tree », Theological Studies, 53 (1997), p. 1000–1029.

Magnano, Fiorella, La teologia ‘topica’ dell’Expositio Psalmorum di Cassiodoro, in XLI Incontro di studiosi dell’Antichità Cristiana: La teologia dal V all’VIII secolo fra sviluppo e crisi, Institutum Patristicum Augustinianum, Roma 2014 (Studia Ephemeridis Augustinianum, 140), p. 361–393.

— « Cicero’s Lists of Topics from Antiquity to the Early Middle Ages », Revista Española de Filosofía Medieval, 22 (2015), p. 85–118.

Martin, Christopher, « The Logic of the Nominales », Vivarium, 30/1 (1992), p. 110–126.

— Logic, in Jeffrey E. Brower, Kevin Guilfroy (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Abelard, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2004, p. 158–199.

— The Development of Abaelard’s Theory of Topical Inference, in Joël Biard, Fosca Mariani Zini (eds.), Les lieux de l’argumentation. Histoire du syllogisme topique d’Aristote à Leibniz, Brepols, Turnhout 2009 (Studia Artistarum, 22), p. 249–270.

Mews, Jan, « On Dating the Works of Peter Abelard », Archives d’histoire doctrinale et littéraire du moyen âge, 52 (1985), p. 73–134.

Papworth, Christian, « Paul, the Olive Tree, and the Wild Olive Branch », Center for Hermeneutical Studies Protocol, 60 (1990).

Peppermüller, Rolf, Abaelards Auslegung des Römerbriefes, Aschendorff, Munich 1972 (Beiträge zur Geschichte der Philosophie und Theologie des Mittelalters, N. F. 10).

— « Exegetische Traditionen und Theologische Neuansätze in Abaelards Kommentar zum Römerbrief », in Éloi Marie Buytaert (ed.), Peter Abelard. Proceedings of the International Conference (Louvain, May 10-12 1971), Leuven University Press–M. Nijhoff, Leuven–The Hague 1974 (Medievalia Lovaniensia, Serie I. Studia, 2).

Rosier-Catach, Irène (ed.), Arts du langage et théologie aux confins des XIe et XIIe siècles. Textes, maitres, débats, Brepols, Turnhout 2011.

Smalley, Beryl, The Study of the Bible in the Middle Ages, Blackwell, Oxford 19843.

Spicq, P. Ceslas, Esquisse d’une histoire de l’exegese latine au Moyen Age, Vrin, Paris 1944 (Bibliotheque Thomiste, 26), p. 399–400.

Valente, Luisa (ed.), Logique et théologie. Les écoles parisiennes entre 1150–1220, Vrin, Paris 2008.

von Moos, Peter, Literary Aesthetics in the Latin Middle Ages: The Rhetorical Theology of Peter Abelard, in C. J. Mews, C. J . Nederman, R. M.Thomson (eds.), Rhetoric and Renewal in the Latin West 1100-1540. Essays in Honour of John O. Ward, Brepols, Turnhout 2003, p. 81–98.