Título de la obra:
Introduction to the Literature of Europe, in the Fifteenth, Sixteenth, and Seventeenth centuries,
vol. 3
Defects of taste in Spanish verse
The original
blemish
of
Spanish
writing both in prose and verse had been an excess of effort to say every thing in an unusual manner, a
deviation
from the beaten paths of sentiment and language in a wider curve tan
good
taste permits. Taste is the presiding faculty which
regulates,
in all works within her jurisdiction, the struggling powers of imagination, emotion, and reason. Each has its claim to mingle in the composition; each may sometimes be allowed in a great measure to predominate; and a phlegmatic application of what men call common sense in aesthetic criticism is almost as repugnant to its principles as a dereliction of all reason for the sake of fantastic absurdity. Taste also must determine, by an intuitive sense of right somewhat analogous to that which regulates the manners of polished life, to what extent the most simple, the most obvious, the most
natural,
and therefore, in a popular meaning, the most true, is to be modified by a studious introduction of the new, the striking, and the beautiful so that neither what is insipid and trivial, nor yet what is
forced
and affected, may displease us. In Spain, as we have observed, the latter was always the prevailing fault. The public taste had been formed on bad models, on the
Oriental
poetry, metaphorical beyond all perceptible analogy, and on that of the Provençals, false in sentiment,
false
in conception, false in image and figure. The
national
character, proud, swelling, and ceremonious, conspired to give an
inflated
tone;
it was also grave and sententious rather than lively or delicate, and therefore fond of a strained and ambitious style. These vices of writing are carried to excess in romances of chivalry, which became ridiculous in the eyes of sensible men, but were certainly very popular; they affect also, though in a different manner, much of the Spanish prose of the
sixteenth
century, and they belong to a great deal of the poetry of that age, though it must be owned that
much
appears wholly
exempt
from them, and written in a very pure and classical spirit.
Cervantes
strove by example and by precept to maintain good taste; and some of his contemporaries took the same line. But they had to fight against the predominant
turn
of their nation, which soon gave the victory to one of the
worst
manners
of writing that ever
disgraced
public favour.